Research shows that learners experience the most brain activity (learning) in response to mistakes, but negative feedback can impact adults’ motivation to learn, so how and when we respond to errors matters immensely.
To learn about these approaches, read this blog about responding to errors with ESL students or watch this video about celebrating mistakes in math. Interested in learning more? Share your thoughts, experiences or questions with PropelNM here or dig deeper with the resources below.
Tutor Tip: Did you know that making a mistake puts your "brain on pause"? Many of us have heard of Carol Dweck's work into the growth mindset and recognize that making mistakes are a big part of how we learn. However, we do need a little time after making mistakes to digest, reflect, and reset. It's important to remember this when working with students. Are you providing that time? CLICK HERE TO READ MORE
We all make mistakes and learn from them. Do you show your own mistakes and talk about them with your students? This is the first step: the awareness by all that errors are inevitable and needed. The next step is to ask, what is the purpose of the activity? If we are working with a student who is learning English as a second (or third, or fourth) language, the big goal is usually effective communication. If that is the case, it is important not to interrupt your student when they are communicating, as well as to not correct them above their level (because what good does that do?).
If the goal is accuracy in a specific email that the student will be sending in real life, then that is entirely different and might go through a writing process with editing and correction as the final step. If the entire class is struggling with a specific area, then it makes sense to approach that as a mini-lesson for everyone without singling anyone out.
Since we also want students to be able to spot their own mistakes, then wait time, or pausing, also matters. If this is difficult, can we point them in the direction of where a mistake might be, be it in spoken or written communication?
What about when students ask to be corrected? Check out the resources below to reflect on this important question!
Note: The above tips are based on the Macmillan Education blog by Sarah Hillyard "Let Them Speak: Tackling Oral Error Correction" that you can listen to or read here: Let Them Speak: Tackling Oral Error Correction. You can read or listen to it here.
To Correct Or Not to Correct
To get started, read the quick tip or watch the brief videos below:
(Article) Read about The Dos & Donts of Error Correction When Teaching English | TEFL Blog, News, Tips & Resources and Focused Error Correction
(Video) Mindset Kit: Three ways to celebrate mistakes in class, Celebrate Mistakes
(Video) Learning from Mistakes: How to Promote Effective Error Correction
Go further:
Get the Teacher Toolkit from Literacy MN:
~Watch live examples: MN Literacy Council's Teacher Training Toolkit: Error Correction and Feedback
~Complete the handouts in the toolkit.
~Ready to give it a try? Mimic the techniques from the video.
Consider the following questions:
How do you respond to student errors? Do you have techniques that are especially effective? Are there times when you choose not to address them?
How do your learners respond when they realize they’ve made a mistake?
What do you do and say that encourages either a growth or fixed mindset?
Then, reflect on the information and questions in this blog.
Have you tried using any of the techniques? How did it go? Are you interested in trying them but need a little support? Are there other techniques that work well for you?
📝Share your experience, questions, and suggestions using this form.📝
Want to learn what's behind the discussion? Explore the research:
Share Your Thoughts
Did you learn something new here? Try implementing it in your instruction! Let us know how it goes or ask for clarification or support using this feedback form!
Would you like to learn about another topic? Explore the Instructional Learning Library here or suggest a topic on the above form.